News 
 World News 
 World 
 General 
 The wrath of women scorned 

The wrath of women scorned

23/08/2008 1:00:01 AM

TO THE end, they made her their winner. "Hill-ary … the nominee", they chanted in the filled underground Manhattan gymnasium where Hillary Clinton held her final victory celebration. Five months of campaigning ended with a win in South Dakota but the media were telling her she was finished. This was a victory to be relished.

Within that crucible of enthusiasm and occasional despair, Carla Usher was electric, celebrating Clinton's refusal to yield. "It's not over. It's not over. I am so excited," she told friends. Almost three months later, Usher, 39, a mature-age journalism student, is part of a network of disenchanted Clinton supporters that will not go quietly.

Their excitement has hardened to a resolve that the Democratic presidential nomination should have been settled at next week's national convention in Denver. Instead, the convention will be a coronation, not a contest. In the wake is a raft of Clinton loyalists turning away from the party.

Usher says that of a New York "Hillary's women" group that has stayed in touch, about a third have vowed to vote for John McCain, the Republican presidential candidate, so convinced are they of the unfairness of Clinton's treatment and Barack Obama's lack of readiness for the White House.

Opinion polls suggest one in four Clinton Democrats feel similarly aggrieved. A Rasmussen July 31 poll found 30 per cent of conservative Democrats intended to vote for McCain, and a CNN poll in June found 22 per cent of Clinton supporters intended abstaining, while 17 per cent would vote for McCain.

She knows so much about the issues so many of us care about, like families and children and education and the future. She can speak on any issue … the history of it, the future of it, why it matters. When [Obama] first arrived on the scene I was open to him, but then he started talking and everything he said was just corny. I can't imagine pulling the lever for that guy. No way. - Jessi Cleaver

They are at pains to say it's not sour grapes; it's about experience. Marnie Delano says: "Hillary's qualified and he is not. He has no track record. He has not written any bills, no laws, he has no foreign policy experience."

Usher says that unlike most other candidates - including Obama - Clinton spent years shaping and creating policy, and campaigning for women and children.

When the Democratic race was still alive, Clinton sought to emphasise her experience by asking voters who they wanted answering the White House crisis phone at 3am. Russia's invasion of Georgia was a "3am moment", says Michael Borio, a Clinton volunteer from Queens. McCain condemned the Russian response and declared international solidarity with Georgia. "What did Obama do? He basically said they should both refrain from further conflict … like they're equal sides!"

Clinton, these believers argue, was undone by the media.

Sexism trumps racism. There's no question about it so far as the media is concerned. I thought Obama was fine. I liked Hillary very much, but every time the news came on they hammered her … The media is dominated by men and they couldn't stand the idea of a woman president.

Andrew M. Delano, life-long Democrat and Franklin D. Roosevelt's distant cousin.

For media bias, they cite the TV commentator who said Clinton was elected to the Senate only because her husband messed around, or another's remark that whenever Clinton appeared on television he involuntarily crossed his legs. And lots more. Clinton was compared to Glenn Close's bunny-boiling character in Fatal Attraction . Her laugh was compared to a witch's cackle.

Meanwhile, coverage of Obama resembled a love affair.

It's 2008 and it should be OK for a person of colour to choose not to vote for a black candidate … trust me there is a lot that the Obama campaign and its volunteers need to be ashamed of, substantive reasons as to why I found myself unable to reconcile voting for Senator Obama. Carla Usher, Clinton campaign volunteer.

The former Bill Clinton adviser Dick Morris says Hillary would have been saddled with unprecedented political baggage had she been nominated. She generates admiration and dislike in almost equal measure. To Clintonites, the party itself was intent on stopping her.

Her campaigners in the acrimonious Pennsylvania primary were abused as racists, says Jay Kallio, 53, a civil rights activist since his teens. "That's where Hillary's people come from - the civil rights movement," Kallio bristles. "And they call us racist." It was there, in Philadelphia, that Usher was told she should be ashamed of herself, a black woman, for supporting Clinton.

Kallio says: "I am a party stalwart they turn to to get things done in the community. At this point I feel I am fighting for the Democratic Party." He's also preparing to return to Pennsylvania - to campaign for John McCain.

Ian Munro is the Herald 's New York correspondent.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1



28/11/2008 | The fiendish outrage in Mumbai this week will not dent India’s resilience one bit.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...